Carrie Underwood’s fans are accustomed to seeing her wearing a face full of makeup. As a country artist and judge on American Idol, Carrie is often glammed up on stage and TV. But in a rare moment captured at home,

Carrie Underwood surprised fans with a rare makeup-free selfie, and many are now calling for her to embrace a more natural look. The American Idol judge, who recently stepped in to replace Katy Perry,

Carrie Underwood is known for her phenomenal country voice and sassy outfits that show off her toned legs. So fans were understandably thrown off when she debuted a sudden style switch-up—with some claiming she was "unrecognizable.