Let’s take a trip down memory lane… Dave Meltzer didn’t give any WWE matches a 5-star (or better) rating in the 1980s, though Ricky “The Dragon” Steamboat and “Macho Man” Randy ...

Despite that, Roberts has never been able to achieve a 5-star rating, with his highest solo rating being 4.0 and his highest overall match being a 4.5 against Konnan and Cien Caras at AAA La ...

John Cena had only found true opposition in the form of a red hot 'Rated-R Superstar', with Edge twice managing to finagle his way into the WWE Title picture by screwing with 'Big Match John'.

Dave Meltzer never gave a Kurt Angle match five stars Seth Rollins called Dave Meltzer's star ratings silly Kenny Omega ...

According to Dave Meltzer, there is one main event match that he believes could be featured on "The Showcase of the Immortals ...

Despite only winning the first match, both were rated as five-star bouts. In the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Dave Meltzer gave Will Ospreay's match with Fletcher five stars, while his match ...

Having two championships at once is pretty good, but as Kenny Omega proved during his belt collector days, holding three championships at the same time is even better. That idea isn't lost on ...

Dave Meltzer assessed that move. To start, Meltzer has absolutely no idea why AEW hasn't promoted the match, especially given the fact that Wrestle Dynasty is a cross-promotional show featuring ...

The two men were conveniently put in a position where the All In: Texas banner was clearly visible in the background, and that was entirely by design, as Dave Meltzer reports in the Wrestling ...

Read more: Every Match That Dave Meltzer Rated Over 5 Stars Don't miss any of the major wrestling headlines. Sign up to our free newsletter for the biggest stories, sent straight to your inbox.

The final truly sensational match of Jeff Hardy's second run with WWE, this SummerSlam loss came right as he was due to exit the organisation and just before a personally damaging drugs bust at ...